The Architect and the Slave

I’ve not been living long enough to be able to put forth much experiential or historical evidence in support of this, but over the last two years as a freelancer I’ve come to reluctantly accept that capitalism has nearly killed the artisan. In its place we find soulless laborers, toiling robots, cheap conformists with idle hands and mouths to feed. This is the most difficult thing I struggle with in my quest to find a purpose, that all the romance and charm, passion and creativity have been removed from our processes.

We are asked to become human-shaped cogs who bear only the will of our wage-vomiting masters.

As a freelance designer, I’m lucky enough to own my time and sell the products of my labor for what I believe them to be worth. I’m in a much more reasonable position than most workers, but even as such I’m still very negatively affected by the pervasiveness of the mass-marketing, mass-producing culture, especially in regards to the sort of expectations it places in the minds of clients and potential clients.

Recently, in a fit of utter disgust, I googled “I hate freelancing” hoping for an article showcasing some proper commiseration, something that would allow me to breathe and say, “Thank God, I’m not alone.” To my surprise, the top result was a post titled “I hate freelance designers.” (If that wasn’t a sign I’m in the wrong business, I don’t know what is.) More surprising still was that this post was written by a freelance designer. Even knowing the high likelihood that whatever was contained within the post would piss me off, I felt inclined to read it.

The article contained tips for freelance designers that, if followed, would ensure that they maintained a good reputation and continued to attract clients. The second tip started as such:

“Follow the clients instructions to the bone. Don’t cut corners, don’t be creative, don’t crap where you eat. You’re a designer, not fucking Houdini.”

To which I adamantly protested, “Oh, but I *am* fucking Houdini!”

Am I to believe that designers are meant to be bullshit corporate hacks, obeying, without question, the unsatisfying monotony and conformity requested by unskilled entrepreneurs, marketers and management for the sole purpose of pushing wholly unremarkable products on poor souls who have no real use for them? Are freelancers in general just glorified cogs relegated to collectively fellating the flailing dicks of corporate America? I think not. If I did, I wouldn’t be playing this game.

Potential clients (whether small businesses, large companies, or single-person operations) approach me with this view, though. “He is not an artist,” they say, “but a necessary cog in our machine and he should stay in place and do as we say since we’ll pay him.” And what I do clearly cannot be art, but dead soulless commodity. Surely a designer is just a prostitute who paints.

Bullshit.

I am a skilled worker and I am an artisan and I expect to be treated as such even if this means never again being afforded the opportunity to work. I am not an assembly line or a support team or a servant to be at anyone’s beck and call. If someone knows exactly what they want such-and-such a thing to look like and how they want it to operate, they don’t need a designer. They need an assembler. This is the difference between the architect and the slave.

The architect draws the plans, designs the building, chooses the materials, defines the details and orchestrates the construction. His expertise is required, praised, appreciated, necessary. Few people would refute the claim that architecture is art and the architect an artist.

The slave, on the other hand, is a brick mover, a mortar layer, an assembler who operates by threat of the whip. He has no part in the design of what he builds, though his weathered hands likely have some advice worth following. He is only expected to mindlessly obey the direction of his masters, whatever their will, however uneducated their design or futile their wishes so that he might go on to live another day.

Freelancers ought not be the slaves.

I can’t fault anybody for doing what it takes for them to eat, but, speaking for myself, I can no longer count myself in this number who so faithfully balance the non-working entrepreneurs on their backs. I want, first, for what I do to be just, second, for what I do to be appreciated and, third, for what I do to go toward some meaningful cause rather than perpetuating the private tyrannies and lining the pockets of lazy profiteers.

Design, I do believe, has the ability to shape the world. It can influence people to actions they might not have otherwise taken. This is a very dangerous thing. A designer can convince you to buy another iPod or to participate in food drives and unfortunately most of the truly talented designers have been lost to shit-peddling because it pays better.

If you freelance or plan to freelance, take the time to think about what you can do with your abilities to actually make a difference in the world while you earn your living. If anyone has any ideas, let me know. I’m still trying to figure it out myself.


Related posts

  1. Online Businesses You Can Start Today, Part One – Web Design
  2. Diary of a Wage Slave Rebel: The Truth About Working For Yourself
  3. The Unfortunate Pervasiveness of Object Over Imagination
  4. Diary of a Wage Slave Rebel: When Preparation Meets Imogen Heap


10 Responses to The Architect and the Slave
  1. Gordie Rogers
    November 5, 2009 | 10:00 am

    Actually, the Internet is allowing the artisan to make a comeback in someways. It has leveled the playing field for the small guys in some ways. I agree that artisans sell themselves out for money.

    • jdbentley
      November 10, 2009 | 6:43 pm

      I agree completely. This is one of the things I love about the internet. Artisans can set up a worldwide storefront and have access to a massive global market for very little cost. And sites like Foodzie.com, Etsy.com and Lulu.com really help to facilitate that. Yay internet.

  2. Diggy Upgradereality
    November 5, 2009 | 1:24 pm

    Hey JD!
    Whatsup?!

    I totally agree with you that designers should not follow the instructions of a client blindly. I myself am not very good at design, and when I want something designed, I prefer to just say "be creative and come up with something cool".

    Designers get paid to do exactly that. Design. Clients should give rough guidelines if they want something specific, but it is up to the artist to create the art :)

    Cheers!

    • jdbentley
      November 10, 2009 | 6:44 pm

      Thank you! Rough guidelines is always what I want. Guidelines are the limits that induce creativity. I hate when people come to me with too many details or a design already worked out in their head.

  3. Rasheed Hooda
    November 5, 2009 | 1:35 pm

    Interesting post, JD

    Obviously you're mad at the affairs of things and it shows. Self expression is good, and as artists and artisans, we are good at expressing ourselves.

    I freelance my art, though fundamentally different from yours, art nonetheless. I twist long skinny balloons into shapes and figures for the entertainment of children of all ages, from 2 to 92 (my oldest customer is actually 94). I do this for profits and fun.

    When I first started this almost two years ago, I was started it for profits alone. I was looking for a way to make enough to pay the bills so I can focus on pursuing what I love, which at that time I thought was being a motivational speaker and seminar organizer. I soon found out, by accident, that if I was having fun while doing what I did, I make more money. When I am working to make money, I make less.

    As I said earlier, I do this for profits and fun. Profits is the first focus of my operation, and I found out that if I was focused on having fun while doing what I needed to do, I made more profits.

    When your focus is making a difference, then focus on it, and soon you'll find out that the world will gladly pay you ample wages for you to continue making a difference.

    • jdbentley
      November 10, 2009 | 6:45 pm

      You make balloon animals?!? That is the weirdest and most awesome thing I have ever heard. You are a true artisan!

  4. Colin Wright
    November 5, 2009 | 2:24 pm

    I would argue that the increased presence of sites like Guru.com and Elance.com are good for people like us…people who are Creatives, not 'logo-makers' or 'Photoshoppers.'

    These sites generally underpay and create a system where the one who obeys the most (and in a lot of cases, is willing to do work for no pay in a contest-style arena) creates a bottom rung where people can easily make a few bucks, but also serves the purpose of making it clear exactly where that rung is.

    Because of this, anyone who does something on another level has a much better chance of being recognized for it. When 99.99% of what's out there is shit, the gold looks even shinier. The comparisons become that much easier to make.

    This is not to say that I don't still have a difficult time explaining to people why I charge a whole lot more than other designers they've worked with. Usually I just tell them 'You know, I can recommend someone else who can do this for you at the price you are looking for, and you'll get something very serviceable.' Being willing to turn away clients who don't fit my ideal client standards has helped me immensely by freeing up time and freeing my mind from the really tedious projects.

    I could go on for ages about this, but you've more or less said most of what I believe on the subject. Really insightful stuff, as always.

  5. Nate
    November 5, 2009 | 10:12 pm

    I like how you distinguish the difference between designers and assemblers. There is a difference, and it should be noted by employers before they even start looking through workers/freelancers. With that being said, I don't think it's necessarily wrong for an employer to expect something done a certain way, they just need to make sure that the worker is willing to do things that way. If they aren't they should look elsewhere. Really insightful post man hope things are going well.

  6. WJ TILLY
    November 7, 2009 | 3:27 pm

    It's a sobering thought…. I'm a slave … a toiling robot… Joe vs The Volcano…. Where were you 36 years ago!!!!

  7. Thomas
    November 9, 2009 | 11:57 pm

    Dude, so true and so eloquent. I don't want to be treated as expense, I want to be treated as a person and appreciated.

    I do feel sorry for those i high places though. They were born free and have been suckered into their position as well; they've just got the blinders on.

Leave a Reply


Wanting to leave an <em>phasis on your comment?

CommentLuv Enabled
Trackback URL http://wageslaverebel.com/the-architect-and-the-slave/trackback/
430 SUBSCRIBERS Subscribe
GET FREE UPDATES BY: RSS or Email
Hey, I'm JD. Last year, I started Wage Slave Rebel as a resource for those who are dying to escape from conformity and design the lifestyles they dream of! I write about online entrepreneurship, productivity, and lifestyle design. Learn more about Wage Slave Rebel

Feel free to contact me or follow me on Twitter.